Friday, July 10, 2026

Preview: "The Defender of the Faith" and "King Charles the Martyr"

Just before the hosts and the engineer of Son Rise Morning Show went off to their summer vacation after the Independence Day Holiday, I mentioned to Anna Mitchell how King Charles III has announced a slight change in his approach to being the Supreme Governor of the Church of England and Defender of the Faith. So she thought we should talk about that on Monday, July 13 during our regular Son Rise Morning Show segment, and I also looked at John Keble's The Christian Year poems, and found one about another King Charles--Charles I of England, Scotland and Wales, under the title of "King Charles the Martyr."

The change or addition to King Charles III's role in the Church of England was announced in "the Sovereign Grant Report 2025-26, and expands on the monarch’s responsibilities compared with last year’s version." According to this website:
The previous report described the King simply as the “Head of the Church of England and Defender of the Faith.” The latest edition adds a broader emphasis on religious inclusion, stating: “His Majesty is Supreme Governor of the Church of England and protects the space for Faith within the multi-faith nation.”

The revised wording reflects King Charles’ long-standing commitment to interfaith dialogue, a cause he has championed since his time as Prince of Wales. Throughout his public life, the King has regularly engaged with representatives of Jewish, Muslim, Sikh, Orthodox and other religious communities in the UK and overseas, often speaking about cooperation among the Abrahamic faiths.
In 2023 before his May 6 Coronation, we talked about the Coronation Oaths that Charles would take--with some history about the changes in the Oath regarding the Catholic Church.

The website above reminds us:
Before his coronation in 2023, there had been speculation that Charles might adopt the title “Defender of Faith” rather than the traditional “Defender of the Faith,” signalling a broader commitment to all religions. However, he ultimately retained the historic title used by previous British monarchs.
Gavin Ashenden, former Anglican bishop and Chaplain to Queen Elizabeth II from 2008 to 2017, who became a Catholic in 2019, thinks that Charles III has relinquished his title as "Defender of the Faith", meaning of the Anglican Church, its doctrine, the Thirty-Nine Articles, etc. 

I'm not so sure since the Church of England has in several ways followed the spirit of the age, and may be occupying that "space" already (Carl Trueman in the article cited below has the same idea), and has been in decline in members and attendance for some years. Ashenden also comments on what the "space" or nexus of a "multi-faith nation" is and who occupies it (noting that Muslims might not accept such a space!) Is the monarch going to engage in ecumenical dialogue or just go to different religious events? Ashenden comments on the possibility of abdication, but who in Parliament would require it? Does it matter to the people of England?

Carl Trueman also notes in "No Faith Worth Defending" for First Things that multi-culturalism is the only way for the people of England to view religion, because the nation "no longer has any understanding of what religion is and why it is important." Or, as Saint John Henry Newman said in his biglietto speech on May 12, 1879, describing the phenomenon of the spirit of liberalism in religion (the anti-dogmatic principle) and its "doctrines" (!):
Revealed religion is not a truth, but a sentiment and a taste; not an objective fact, not miraculous; and it is the right of each individual to make it say just what strikes his fancy. Devotion is not necessarily founded on faith. Men may go to Protestant Churches and to Catholic, may get good from both and belong to neither. They may fraternise together in spiritual thoughts and feelings, without having any views at all of doctrine in common, or seeing the need of them. Since, then, religion is so personal a peculiarity and so private a possession, we must of necessity ignore it in the intercourse of man with man. If a man puts on a new religion every morning, what is that to you? It is as impertinent to think about a man's religion as about his sources of income or his management of his family. Religion is in no sense the bond of society.
And what does this mean for Catholics in England? Does it really matter to them what the monarch's role is in the official Anglican Church? May this change lead to more Anglicans converting and joining the Anglican Ordinariate?

So we'll discuss these issues on Monday, July 13, and I look forward to Anna's or Matt's thoughts.

In contrast--we probably won't have any time to discuss this at all!--some members of the Church of English--the highest High Church Anglicans!--reverence King Charles I as a martyr of the Faith (a Defender of the Anglican Faith to the end). Lord Nicholas Windsor (a convert to Catholicism like his mother, the late Duchess of Kent) wrote this introduction on the Society of King Charles the Martyr's homepage:
May I welcome you to these web-pages of The Society of King Charles the Martyr with the hope that you will find their contents interesting and informative. Although a small society we remain very active and lively in providing a fitting organisation to keep the memory of the life and death of King Charles. It was the Blessed John Henry Newman who recalled the Church to remember ‘our own Saint Charles’ and John Keble who wrote, ‘It is as natural that the Church of England should keep this day [30th January] as it is that Christ’s Universal Church should keep Saint Stephen’s martyrdom.’ In the King’s personal piety, devotion and support of the Church, his ecumenical understanding (far advanced for his day), his patronage of the Arts in the service of God, his inspiration of the Christian classic, Eikon Basilike and of course his martyrdom, we have much to REMEMBER and be thankful for.”
(Obviously before Newman's canonization!) Lord Nicholas Windsor is "the first male blood royal to become Catholic since Charles II [on his deathbed]" and of course, he was removed from the succession rolls.

And here is Keble's poem for the martyr king's feast:

King Charles the Martyr.
This is thankworthy, if a man for conscience toward God endure grief, suffering wrongfully. 1 St. Peter ii. 19.

Praise to our pardoning God! though silent now
   The thunders of the deep prophetic sky,
Though in our sight no powers of darkness bow
   Before th’ Apostles’ glorious company;

The Martyrs’ noble army still is ours,
   Far in the North our fallen days have seen
How in her woe this tenderest spirit towers
   For Jesus’ sake in agony serene.

Praise to our God! not cottage hearths alone,
   And shades impervious to the proud world’s glare,
Such witness yield; a monarch from his throne
   Springs to his Cross and finds his glory there.

Yes: whereso’er one trace of thee is found,
   As in the Sacred Land, the shadows fall:
With beating hearts we roam the haunted ground,
   Lone battle-field, or crumbling prison hall.

And there are aching solitary breasts,
   Whose widowed walk with thought of thee is cheered
Our own, our royal Saint: thy memory rests
   On many a prayer, the more for thee endeared.

True son of our dear Mother+, early taught
   With her to worship and for her to die,
Nursed in her aisles to more than kingly thought,
   Oft in her solemn hours we dream thee nigh.

For thou didst love to trace her daily lore,
   And where we look for comfort or for calm,
Over the self-same lines to bend, and pour
   Thy heart with hers in some victorious psalm.

And well did she thy loyal love repay;
   When all forsook, her Angels still were nigh,
Chained and bereft, and on thy funeral way,
   Straight to the Cross she turned thy dying eye

And yearly now, before the Martyrs’ King,
   For thee she offers her maternal tears,
Calls us, like thee, to His dear feet to cling,
   And bury in His wounds our earthly fears.

The Angels hear, and there is mirth in Heaven,*
   Fit prelude of the joy, when spirits won
Like those to patient Faith, shall rise forgiven,
   And at their Saviour’s knees thy bright example own.

+Mother=the Church of England I think (not the Blessed Virgin Mary)
*"There is joy in the presence of the angels of God over one sinner that repenteth." (St. Luke 15:10)

Image Source (Public Domain): The Eikon Basilike, a purported spiritual autobiography attributed to Charles I, published days after his execution.

No comments:

Post a Comment