Friday, May 6, 2011

Reflections on the Royal Wedding

I did not think that I would have time to watch the Royal Wedding early in the morning on Friday, April 29 because my husband and I were getting ready to drive to a friend's wedding three and a half hours away later that day. But he encouraged me to watch some of the ritual. Born and raised in the USA, I cried when they sang "God Save the Queen." And I also cried when they sang "Jerusalem", because it's just so glorious. And I just wished that Diane Sawyer and the ABC News crew would quit talking about all the incidentals and concentrate on the reality of the wedding.

Some weeks before the Royal Wedding I happened to see a segment on one of those silly celebrity shows featuring supplies for those who wanted to be in London that day. The supplies included things like barf bags and packages of condoms(!), all emblazoned with William and Kate's pictures. Like Diane Sawyer and Robin Roberts, they really did not understand the reality of the wedding. It was not just a fancy dress day; the couple will someday soon announce the birth of a child to continue the succession; perhaps not as quickly as the father hoped in Yentl, but sometime in the not-too-distant future.

The sermon from the Anglican Bishop of London, the hymns chosen for the ceremony--

"Guide Me, O Thou Great Redeemer" (which was sung at Prince Williams' mother's memorial service in 2008)
"Love Divine, All Loves Excelling" (by Charles Wesley)
"Ubi Caritas et Amor"
"Jerusalem" (by William Blake and known to American audiences, as the news anchors intoned "from the movie Chariots of Fire")
"Blest Pair of Sirens" (by John Milton), not to mention
"God Save the Queen" (the National Anthem)

--the ritual of the wedding ceremony, the prayers of the Bishop and the Archbishop of Canterbury, and the prayer the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge wrote indicated the reality of the day: they are giving themselves to each other in the service of their country, of their people. This was not just another celebrity wedding with some additional pomp and circumstance.

Elena Maria Vidal linked to a great article from the Daily Mail in which columnist Melanie Phillips commented:

For here was one of the most striking aspects of that day. We are repeatedly told that Britain has now left religion far behind. And similarly, traditional marriage is said to be a thing of the past.

But last Friday, people in this apparently godless nation were held spellbound by a wedding ceremony which was explicitly not just religious but Christian.

What was even more notable was the special prayer composed by the happy couple themselves.

For in this they prayed for help to focus on the important things in life, to serve and to help the needy — all ‘in the spirit of Jesus’.

This was in effect an explicit dedication of themselves to a life of service to the nation on behalf of the Christian institution of the monarchy.


I just hope that if Charles, the Prince of Wales, does survive his mother, he leaves the coronation ceremony alone and ensures the continuity demonstrated by this Royal Wedding.

More on Syon Abbey

I posted a brief excerpt about the original Syon Abbey from the Syon Park website on May 4.

The history goes on to explain what happened after the dissolution of the Abbey in 1539:

After the suppression of the abbey, the estate became Crown property and became the possession of the 1st Duke of Somerset, the Lord Protector to the young son of King Henry VIII, Edward VI. He built Syon House in the Italian Renaissance style, over the foundations of the west end of the huge abbey church, (which was the size of a cathedral), between 1547 and his death by execution in 1552. Syon was then acquired by a rival, John Dudley, Duke of Northumberland (no relation to the present family.) The Duke's son, Lord Guildford Dudley, had married Lady Jane Grey, the great-granddaughter of King Henry VII and it was at Syon that she was formally offered the Crown by the Duke. She accepted reluctantly, was conveyed to London by river and proclaimed Queen. Nine days later, she was displaced by King Henry VIII's eldest daughter, Mary Tudor. The following year Lady Jane Grey was executed. In 1557, the Roman Catholic Queen Mary recalled the nuns to re-establish their abbey at Syon. But she died suddenly in 1558 and the nuns left the country on the accession of her Protestant sister, Queen Elizabeth I. (In 1861 the nuns returned to England to found their religious community in Devon, where they reside to this day). In 1594, Henry Percy, 9th Earl of Northumberland, acquired Syon through his marriage to Dorothy Devereux and the Percy family has lived at Syon House ever since.

The history page also includes this link to a description of excavations and information about the "Lost Abbey of Sion".

One event the history omits is that Catherine Howard was kept sequestered in the former abbey while Henry VIII and his courtiers investigated the charges of treason against her. Then she was moved to the Tower of London when Parliament passed a Bill of Attainder against her, in preparation for her execution.

Thursday, May 5, 2011

Bess of Hardwick: Formidable Indeed!

Once I Was a Clever Boy featured this post of "Bess of Hardwick (1527-1608), the remarkable self-made, or self-improving, Derbyshire woman who became the matriarch of the Cavendish family."

I read her biography a few years ago by Mary S. Lovell--since Bess and her fourth husband the Earl of Shrewsury "hosted" the imprisoned Queen of Scots, Mary Stuart, great pressures came to bear on their finances and their already contentious marriage.

Bess of Hardwick's granddaughter Arbella is another fascinating figure of the the Stuart era--but not that much connected to the issues of the English Reformation.

Wednesday, May 4, 2011

May 4th, Feast of the English Catholic Martyrs

Six years ago on this feast day of the Catholic Martyrs of the English Reformation, Anglican Bishop Richard Chartres of London and Catholic Auxiliary Bishop George Stack of Westminster held an ecumenical service in honor of the first Catholic martyrs under Henry VIII. Catholic News Service carried the story the next day:

"We who today give thanks to the witness of these Carthusian martyrs and the martyrs of every age may not be called upon to die for the faith that we profess, but there is no doubt that, whatever our Christian tradition, each of us who believe are challenged to live for that faith by Jesus Christ, the king of martyrs who gave his life as a ransom for all of us," he said.

Red roses, each representing a martyr, were then placed into a model of the "Tyburn Tree," the triangular London gallows where 105 Catholics were executed during the Reformation.

St. John was the first of four priests hanged May 4, 1535, after they were convicted of treason for refusing to take the oath of the Act of Supremacy, the law that made the king the supreme leader of the Church of England.

St. Thomas More, watching their departure from the window of his cell in the Tower of London, remarked to his daughter, Margaret, how the men went "to their deaths as cheerfully as bridegrooms to their marriage."

St. John was said to have remained conscious throughout an ordeal that involved partial hanging and disembowelment.

[N.B.: The execution of the Carthusians was made more torturous by the fact that they wore their habits and St. John also wore a hair shirt.]

Two other Carthusian abbots, St. Robert Lawrence and St. Augustine Webster, and a Brigittine monk, St. Richard Reynolds, were executed in the hours that followed.Afterward, King Henry ordered one of St John's arms to be nailed over the main entrance of the Charterhouse as a warning to others.

Within five years, six more Carthusians were executed and nine others tied to posts and starved to death in London's Marshalsea Prison.St. John, St. Robert, St. Augustine and St. Richard were among 40 English and Welsh martyrs canonized by Pope Paul VI in 1970. May 4 is the feast of the English and Welsh martyrs.

According to the Archbishop of Canterbury's website, the death of the Carthusians and St. Richard Reynolds has been remembered with such as service since 2004:

Since 2004 there has been a Commemoration of the Carthusian Martyrs at Sutton's Hospital each year.

In 2005 the Bishop of London attended with Bishop George Stack representing the Cardinal.

In 2006 the Commemoration was combined with a Requiem for Fr Geoffrey Curtis CR who caused the Carthusian Martyrs' Memorial to be erected at Sutton's Hospital on the site of the ancient Priory Church.

In 2007 the first public Roman Catholic Service was held since the Reformation - Latin Vespers were sung by the Choristers of Westminster Cathedral and Monsignor Mark Langham, Administrator of Westminster Cathedral, gave the address.

In 2008 the preacher was Bishop John Flack who had been the Director of
the Anglican Centre in Rome.

In 2009 the homily was by Cardinal Cormac Murphy O'Connor but sadly he was unable to deliver it in person – Bishop George Stack did so. The Apostolic Nuncio was in attendance and read the Second Lesson.


And in 2010 Rowan Williams delivered the sermon I commented on last year--reflecting on Henry VIII, Hell, Robert Aske in H.F.M. Prescott's novel, and St. John Houghton.

Before he died, St. John prayed the first six verses of Psalm 31 and his last words are reported as "Jesus, Jesus, what will you do with my heart?":

In finem. Psalmus David, pro extasi: In te, Domine, speravi; non confundar in æternum : in justitia tua libera me. Inclina ad me aurem tuam; accelera ut eruas me. Esto mihi in Deum protectorem, et in domum refugii, ut salvum me facias: quoniam fortitudo mea et refugium meum es tu; et propter nomen tuum deduces me et enutries me. Educes me de laqueo hoc quem absconderunt mihi, quoniam tu es protector meus. In manus tuas commendo spiritum meum; redemisti me, Domine Deus veritatis.

Since the Vatican approved the revised liturgical calendar for England and Wales, this May 4th Feast there has honored both the 40 martyrs Pope Paul VI canonized in 1970 and the 85 martyrs Blessed John Paul II beatified in 1987.

St. Richard Reynolds, "The Angel of Syon"

I've blogged about St. John Houghton and the Carthusians of the Charterhouse of London before, but have not yet focused on St. Richard Reynolds of the Bridgettine House of Syon. St. Richard was also executed on May 4, 1535. This website offers some information (with a few errors--St. John Fisher was not executed before the Carthusians and St. Richard, as the article states!):

Further turning the King against the frightened Brigittines (sic) was Richard Reynolds, a priest-confessor. Not only was he exceptionally loyal to the Holy Father but he refused to accept that Henry could divorce his wife, Katherine, and that his monarch could be head of the Church of England.

. . .This infuriated Henry because Father Richard was something of a folk hero. He could not be killed summarily, largely because of the widespread unrest among the laity. So he was brought to trial and interrogated by Chancellor Audley, a successor to St. Thomas More, who also was martyred for maintaining papal authority.

Tragically, Richard got little support from the bishops and senior clergy. They had recently seen the Cardinal Bishop of Rochester, John Fisher, go to the block (sic), and now was not the time for heroics.

In fact, Cardinal Reginald Pole, later the Papal Legate under Queen Mary, lamented that Richard was let down by the bishops. All 19, except St. John Fisher, had agreed to severing ties with Rome, and this acquiescence was used as a cudgel against him. Thus, he was characterized as a rebellious priest who was disloyal to England's hierarchy.

Richard did not yield. According to Cardinal Pole, he kept a level head and reminded Audley that, more importantly, on his side were "all Church general councils, all the historians, the holy doctors of the Church for the past 1,500 years, especially St. Ambrose, St. Jerome, St. Augustine and St. Gregory."



St. Richard Reynolds attended Christ’s College and Corpus Christi College, University of Cambridge and became a Fellow of Corpus Christi in 1510. He then entered the Bridgettine Order in 1513 at Syon Abbey, Ilseworth near London. Noted for his scholarship and personal holiness, he was arrested on April 28, 1535 because he would not acknowledge Henry VIII as the Supreme Head and Governor of the Church in England. This site provides information about Bridgettine life at Syon today (and the portrait of St. Richard above.) It is now located in Devon. The original Syon Abbey is now the home of the Duke of Northumberland. The website includes this note about the history of Syon Abbey, St. Richard Reynolds and Henry VIII:

Originally the site of a medieval abbey, Syon was named after Mount Zion in the Holy Land. The abbey was dedicated to the Bridgettine Order, established in the 14th century by the great Swedish mystic St Bridget. One of the last great abbeys to be built (founded by King Henry V in 1415), Syon was dissolved by King Henry VIII in 1539.

Syon Abbey had become renowned for its spiritual learning, public preaching and library. It was favoured and visited by King Henry VIII’s first wife, Catherine of Aragon but it got embroiled in the religious turmoil of the King’s divorce and his subsequent action of making himself Supreme Head of the Church in England. The Father Confessor, of the nuns, Richard Reynolds, could not accept the King’s supremacy and was brutally executed in 1535, his body placed on the abbey gateway. He was later canonised as a martyr.

In 1547, King Henry VIII's coffin was brought to Syon on its way to Windsor for burial. It burst open during the night and in the morning dogs were found licking up the remains! This was regarded as a divine judgement for the King's desecration of Syon Abbey.

I could not have said it better myself.

Tuesday, May 3, 2011

Digest and Update of Last Year's Posts on the English Martyrs

Because of my focus on Holy Week and on the beatification of Blessed John Paul II, I forgot to mention that I've been blogging for a year (as of April 18) so here are two posts from my 2010 commemoration of the English Martyrs:

A List of the Martyrs, including those canonized by Pope Paul VI and those beatifified by Blessed John Paul II; and

Tyburn Tree, a poem by Francis Thompson.

I have tried to find more information about a planned memorial near the site of Tyburn Tree; as of January in 2009, The Catholic Herald reported on a plan to supplement the plaque located in a traffic island hear Marble Arch in London--

A monument in honour of hundreds of Catholics executed for their faith is to be erected in the heart of central London.

Consultations are underway to instal a striking memorial on the former site of the Tyburn gallows at the western end of Oxford Street, the capital's busiest shopping street.

Between 1535 and 1679 nearly 400 Catholics were executed on the spot, and 105 of these have been recognised by the Vatican as martyrs, with a number canonised as saints.

Since the Fifties the site of the gallows has been marked simply by a stone roundel in a traffic island at the intersection of Edgware Road and Bayswater Road, near to Marble Arch, bearing the image of a plain black cross and the words: "The site of the Tyburn Tree."

But Westminster City Council has begun looking for ideas for a more fitting memorial. . . .

Tyburn became a place of public execution in the 12th century, and, as the "King's gallows", was used in particular for those people convicted of capital offences against the Crown.

The first martyrs of the Protestant Reformation - St John Houghton and companions - were executed together for treason there on May 4 1535 after they refused to accept King Henry VIII as the head of the Church in England.

In 1571 Queen Elizabeth I erected the Tyburn Tree, triangular gallows purposely built for multiple executions, with 24 men and women executed there together in one instance.

Catholics to die there included St Edmund Campion, the first English Jesuit martyr, who wrote in his "brag" to Elizabeth's Privy Council, that the Jesuits would never cease to work for the conversion of England "while we have a man left to enjoy your Tyburn".

The last Catholic Tyburn martyr was St Oliver Plunkett, the Archbishop of Armagh, executed on July 1 1679, the last of 25 innocent victims of the Titus Oates plot.

Most men were hanged, drawn and quartered - a slow death that involved castration and disemboweling before the head was struck off and the body quartered - but Catholic women, such as Mary Ward [sic--the writer meant Margaret Ward] and Anne Line, were hanged instead.

The Tyburn Convent honors the martyrs on their website.

Oh, Sons and Daughters

This is one of my favorite Easter hymns, John Mason Neale's translation of the medieval Latin hymn O fil­ii et fil­i­ae, Rex coe­les­tis, Rex glor­i­ae by Jean Tisserand:

O sons and daughters, let us sing!
The King of Heaven, the glorious King,
Over death today rose triumphing.
Alleluia! Alleluia!

That Easter morn, at break of day,
The faithful women went their way
To seek the tomb where Jesus lay.
Alleluia! Alleluia!

An angel clad in white they see,
Who sat, and spake unto the three,
“Your Lord doth go to Galilee.”
Alleluia! Alleluia!

That night th’apostles met in fear;
Amidst them came their Lord most dear,
And said, “My peace be on all here.”
Alleluia! Alleluia!

When Thomas first the tidings heard,
How they had seen the risen Lord,
He doubted the disciples’ word.
Alleluia! Alleluia!

“My piercèd side, O Thomas, see;
My hands, My feet, I show to thee;
Not faithless but believing be.”
Alleluia! Alleluia!

No longer Thomas then denied;
He saw the feet, the hands, the side;
“Thou art my Lord and God,” he cried.
Alleluia! Alleluia!

How blessed are they who have not seen,
And yet whose faith has constant been;
For they eternal life shall win.
Alleluia! Alleluia!

On this most holy day of days
Our hearts and voices, Lord, we raise
To Thee, in jubilee and praise.
Alleluia! Alleluia!

Monday, May 2, 2011

May 4 on the Son Rise Morning Show

The next in my series of brief interviews on the Son Rise Morning Show is scheduled for this Wednesday, May 4 at 7:45 a.m. Eastern/6:45 a.m. Central. Host Brian Patrick and I will discuss the Feast of the English Martyrs of England and Wales, which commemmorates all the Catholic martyrs of the English Reformation era, including those executed under Henry VIII, Elizabeth I, James I, Charles I, and Charles II--I think of them as the Supremacy martyrs, the Recusant martyrs and the Plot martyrs.

The Supremacy martyrs died because they would not swear Henry VIII's Oath of Supremacy and Oath of Succession, which both denied the spiritual, moral, and ecclesiastical authority of the Pope. The Recusant martyrs died during the reigns of Elizabeth I, James I and Charles I because they continued to practice their Catholic faith in England as missionary priests and/or laity in spite of the recusancy and penal laws against them. Finally, the Plot martyrs were executed in the miscarriage of justice called the Popish Plot. Accused of conspiring in a non-existent plot, their Catholicism condemned them.

Brian Patrick and I will focus on the religious executed on May 4, 1535: the Carthusian priors, including St. John Houghton and the Bridgettine confessor, St. Richard Reynolds of Syon Abbey.
You can find a link to listen during the broadcast here and the archived podcast of my interview on Holy Thursday and the Triduum in the Sarum Rite before the English Reformation here.

Sunday, May 1, 2011

Pope John Paul II and the Church of England

As Venerable Servant God John Paul II's beatification occurs today, it is interesting to look back at his funeral, when the cries of "Santo Subito" and "Magnus" echoed throughout St. Peter's square. We recorded NBC News broadcast that day and have watched it a few times. One of the most fascinating comments Brian Williams made at the time was what Pope John Paul II had really lived up John Lennon's Imagine lyrics: "Imagine no possessions . . ." when the author never did himself. On the other hand, all the people there were not just "living for today" and did not try to "Imagine there's no heaven"! (Photo credit: Wikipedia article on Pope John Paul II)

When John Paul II's funeral was scheduled in 2005, something else extraordinary happened: Charles, the Prince of Wales postponed his wedding to Camilla Parker Bowles so that he, the Archbishop of Canterbury and the Prime Minister of England (Tony Blair) could attend that tremendous event in Rome. As the New York Times commented at the time:

It is perhaps one of the stranger, if smaller, ripples to spread from the death of a pope in Rome that Protestants in England should begin to wonder what happened to the power of their faith. But as the funeral of John Paul II on Friday nears, some historians and columnists here have suggested that the English response to his death has shown, in the words of Mark Almond, an Oxford historian, that almost five centuries after its founding, "Protestant England is dead."

Nothing has done more to create that impression than the decision by Prince Charles on Monday to postpone his wedding to Camilla Parker Bowles, initially set for Friday, by one day to permit Prime Minister Tony Blair and the archbishop of Canterbury, the Most Rev. Rowan Williams, head of the Church of England, to attend the papal burial rather than a royal wedding. Even Charles himself--representative of a monarchy that broke with Rome in the 16th century--is planning to attend the funeral on behalf of his mother, Queen Elizabeth II, the head of state. That makes this country one of the few to be represented at the funeral by church, state and government.

"The funeral of a pope, let us be clear, has never until now been the sort of event deemed to require the attendance of the British prime minister--or even the archbishop of Canterbury," Martin Kettle wrote in his column in The Guardian. "It is hard not to catch one's breath at the rupture with national history that all this represents." Or, as Mr. Almond put it, "Henry VIII must be turning in his Windsor grave."

As Mark Almond noted in his original analysis, the "death of Protestantism" did not automatically mean triumphant new life for Catholicism in England. Secularism has replaced Protestantism, not Catholicism. The irony is that England's status as not only a Protestant nation but a fundamentally Christian nation is inscribed by the Coronation Oaths Elizabeth II took so many years ago. She promised not only to maintain the settlement of the Church of England, but to "maintain the Laws of God and the profession of the Gospel."A reader of this blog sent me his analysis of the Coronation Oaths and noted that Queen Elizabeth II did not receive any of the emblems of her official rule over the kingdom until she had promised to uphold the Church of the England and God's laws.

As another Royal Wedding has just taken place, observers wonder how long the special relationship between the Church of England and the monarchy will last. A columnist in The Independent suggests that the Church of England might benefit from disestablishment. Catholics and the Catholic Church in England need to follow the leadership that Pope John Paul II demonstrated especially during his visits in 1982, showing that England's Catholic heritage is alive and well--and the new members of Pope Benedict XVI's Ordinariate, Our Lady of Walsingham under the spiritual guidance of Blessed John Henry Newman will help them do just that. Blessed John Paul II, pray for us!

Discrimination and the Act of Settlement

Recently, the 1701 Act of Settlement has been in the news! See here and here. That act prevents a Catholic (Roman or Eastern Rite) from being the monarch or even being married to the monarch. The Official Website of the British Monarchy explains it thus:

The Act of Settlement of 1701 was designed to secure the Protestant succession to the throne, and to strengthen the guarantees for ensuring parliamentary system of government. The Act also strengthened the Bill of Rights (1689), which had previously established the order of succession for Mary II’s heirs. . . .

According to the 1701 Act, succession to the throne went to Princess Sophia, Electress of Hanover (James I's granddaughter) and her Protestant heirs. However, Sophia died before Queen Anne, therefore the succession passed to her son, George, Elector of Hanover, who in 1714 became King George I. The act was later extended to Scotland as a result of the Treaty of Union enacted in the Acts of Union of 1707.

The Act also laid down the conditions under which alone the Crown could be held. No Roman Catholic, nor anyone married to a Roman Catholic, could hold the English Crown. The Sovereign now had to swear to maintain the Church of England (and after 1707, the Church of Scotland).

In the interests of non-discrimination, some members of Parliament have been suggesting that restriction should be removed. No other religious identity prevents one from being monarch or spouse--should/could a practicing Jew really swear to maintain the Church of England--or an avowed atheist? Recently Nick Clegg, the Deputy Prime Minister had started negotiations to remove this restriction, but the effort has been stopped.

Damian Thompson, linked above, believes that Queen Elizabeth II herself may have stopped it:

"The Queen takes very seriously her coronation oath to uphold the Protestant religion. I wouldn’t dream of accusing her of anti-Catholic prejudice, but suspicion of Rome runs deep in her family. Matters have not been helped by Pope Benedict’s creation of a new ecclesial structure for departing members of the Church of England: the Ordinariate did not play well in royal circles. I suspect that a message has been conveyed to the Lambeth Palace about the inadvisability of changes to the Act in the current climate. And so we are left with a situation in which, if Prince Harry falls in love with a Catholic, he will have to step out of the line of succession – but if the girl is a Scientologist or a practising witch, that’s no problem."

Some have noted that this Act is the one thing that maintains Christianity as the official religion of Great Britain. Some might also say that it hasn't been very effective!