Showing posts with label Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 5, 2026

Book Review: Part Two: Nussbaum on Mozart's two "Masonic" Operas


Earlier this year when I reviewed Dietrich von Hildebrand's MOZART BEETHOVEN SCHUBERT from the Hildebrand Project I mentioned that he did not include any of Mozart's opera seria (Lucio Silla, Idomeneo, or La Clemenza di Tito). He referenced Mozart's Freemasonry and highlighted Die Zauberflöte, admitting the Masonic influence on that work:

It is true that Mozart was a Freemason, for at that time Freemasonry was not yet seen as incompatible with the Catholic faith [sic*]. This humanitarian fraternization was so much in fashion that Mozart and his father Leopold Mozart were Freemasons. But both were above all devout Catholics. . . .

Mozart's only significant work in which one could find a relation to Freemasonry is "The Magic Flute." . . . (page 20) 

They are not significant but Mozart did compose several Masonic themed works for specific lodge events in Vienna. 

*Since Pope Clement XII in 1738 had issued In eminenti apostolatus specula, forbidding Catholics to join Masonic lodges, I think that von Hildebrand is wrong.

But Martha Nussbaum argues in The Republic of Love that Mozart's 1781 opera seria, Idomeneo, Rei di Creta shows the influence of that "humanitarian fraternization" particularly in the characters of Idamante, the son of Idomeneo, and Ilia, the Trojan princess whom Idamante loves and who loves Idamante in spite of herself. Although Mozart had not yet joined a lodge in Vienna when he wrote Idomeneo, she notes he was already attracted to the fellowship and spirit of Freemasonry. 

She finds elements of the "Republic of Love" in this beautiful work, one I've watched on DVD or on-line and listened to several times on CD (the 1982 Metropolitan Opera production; the 1983 Glyndebourne production; the 1991 Philips CD, for example). The Glyndebourne production features a tenor Idamante--there's an earlier (1964) Glyndebourne production with Luciano Pavarotti in that role--he sang Idomeneo's part in the Met production when it premiered in that House. The Met has always had a mezzo-soprano Idamante in its casts, a practice Nussbaum believes appropriate.

2. Mozart and the Freemasons: Idomeneo and The Magic Flute
    Mozart the Freemason
    Mozart's Vienna
    Mozart Joins a Lodge
    Idomeneo: The Reign of Love
    The Magic Flute: Noble Ideals, Imperfect People

Some notes about the first three sections listed above: Nussbaum contends that by 1773 Mozart was drawn to Freemasonry. In Vienna in 1784 he joined the Beneficence Lodge, a more working-class, less elite gathering, and later joined New-Crowned Hope, which absorbed the membership of Beneficence. The Holy Roman Emperor, Joseph II, a man of the Enlightenment, allowed the Masons to gather, but dissolved the Catholic monasteries and convents (and controlled the ordination of priests in his empire). Nussbaum describes this as allowing religious freedom "within the bounds of Enlightenment rationalism" (p. 45). He did, however, reduce the number of Lodges in December, 1795 for fear of secret societies. Nussbaum also notes that the Lodges in Vienna were "not extremely anti-clerical" (p. 46) and that "Mozart was always a practicing Catholic." (p. 47) Among the ideals of Freemasonry Nussbaum cites are equality, brotherhood, the practice of certain rituals, and a calm acceptance of death. 


In the section on Idomeneo, Nussbaum offers an interpretation of the opera that made sense to me, noting the opera seria format with its deus ex machina intervention to resolve the ethical dilemma of the story. In this case the vow King Idomeneo of Crete has made to Neptune if he survives a storm and shipwreck: he will offer as sacrifice the first person he sees on shore. The first person he sees is his son, Idamante. He tries to evade that horrible offering by sending his son away to no avail. Only the intervention of an unidentified "Voice" from the gods to remove him from the throne and bring both Idamante and Ilia, the Trojan princess, to rule Crete brings about the triumph of love at the end.

I mentioned that Nussbaum prefers the casting of a mezzo-soprano Idamante; she believes it highlights both the "close harmonies in the Ilia-Idamante duet [beginning with "S’io non moro a questi accenti,"] and "Idamante's gender-atypical gentleness" because "Idamante [like Cherubino] is a tender, loving type of male who eschews the common male competition for honor and domination." (p. 51). Even his monster-slaying heroics offstage only prepare him for offering himself as the sacrifice required for his country's sake.

Nussbaum dedicates most of the chapter on this opera seria to "tracing two threads that run through [Idomeneo], the ethical growth of Ilia, and the emotional and ethical character of Idamante." (p. 55) Ilia's growth is traced through her three arias as she responds to "Idamante's capacity for love" (p. 57). They are contrasted to Elettra's (aka Electra) desire for revenge and lack of development, and the "well-intentioned but ineffectual" Idomeneo . She concludes with the idea that at the end of the opera, Idamante and Ilia's Crete represents an "enlightened autocracy with a larger space for human choice than was previously available" rather like HRE Joseph II's regime of reform (p. 62). 

Unless, of course, one was called to be a monk or a cloistered nun.

As for Die Zauberflote/The Magic Flute, upon which Mozart collaborated with Emanuel Schikaneder, Nussbaum's main point is that the opera depicts high ideals and tests of those high ideals which reveal both the successes and the failures of the characters to maintain them. She contends that those high "core ideals (reason, steadfastness, wisdom, brotherhood, and love) are those of the Masons (shared, of course, by many Enlightenment non-Masons)" (p. 63)

I think many non-Enlightenment, non-Masons have shared those ideals: they aren't exclusively Enlightenment-era core ideals or virtues.

Parallel to the section on Idomeneo, she emphasizes the ethical growth in Pamina, who leads Tamino through the completion of his initiation and shares the priestly robes in the Temple (like Ilia sharing the throne with Idamante). The two paragraphs on Papageno and Papagena and the three Genii (little boys) offer some rather ordinary insights--she notes how the Genii prevent two suicides (Pamina's and Papageno's) and, of course, that Papageno and Papagena provide most of the humor and the fun of the opera--and the bird catcher is not caught up in the Masonic initiation rites. If, as Nussbaum opines, "In general the opera's message is that one must follow one's own path and question claims to authority." (p. 69), Papageno has rejected those Masonic claims.

The musicologist David Joseph Buch has also rejected an overly Masonic interpretation. For example: 
"Die Zauberflöte, Masonic Opera, and Other Fairy Tales" in Acta Musicologica, [Vol.] 76, [Fasc.] 2 (2004), pp. 193-219 Published by: International Musicological Society. 

Image credit (Public Domain): The Arrival of the Queen of the Night
Image credit (Public Domain): Front page of a bilingual vocal score

Tuesday, July 14, 2026

Book Review, Part One: "The Republic of Love"; Nussbaum on "Le Nozze di Figaro"

I purchased this book from Eighth Day Books. It's from Oxford University Press:

In The Republic of Love, philosopher Martha C. Nussbaum argues that opera engages in political dialogue with the other institutions of public life. Opera interrogates the underlying political culture: what human beings have to be like to sustain different political institutions. Opera’s central contribution, buttressed by the powers of the chorus and the nuances of musical expression, is its exploration of emotions in the structuring of public life, including the role of gender, rank, and class. Nussbaum argues that a distinct Mozartean strand of opera embodies the political project of the Enlightenment. These operas, starting with those of Mozart himself—The Marriage of Figaro, Idomeneo, The Magic Flute, Don Giovanni, Così fan tutte, and La Clemenza di Tito—portray an egalitarian vision, not just of republican political institutions, but of emotion. This vision calls for the rejection of feudal hierarchy based on retributive anger and fear, and an embrace of love. This project has faced complications from the power-politics, tyranny, and oppression of the modern world, and so Mozart’s heirs considered how the Republic of Love can exist despite evil. Nussbaum traces the development of the Mozartean vision from Beethoven’s Fidelio and Verdi’s Don Carlos to Heggie’s Dead Man Walking and Adams’s Nixon in China. Contrasting with this hopeful tradition, Nussbaum considers one antagonist, Richard Wagner, who envisioned a closed and unaccepting society, fearful of strangers, and with eyes forever cast backwards. Ending with hope, Nussbaum examines Verdi’s Falstaff and its joyful and humorous depiction of human frailty.

Eighth Day Books stocks several of her previously published books.

Her focus on Mozart's operas was one of the main reasons I wanted to read this book. I've especially relished the chapter on Le Nozze di Figaro. Nussbaum wrote an essay for Chicago Lyric Opera in 2024 that is very similar to this chapter in The Republic of Love:

1. Equality and Love at the End of "The Marriage of Figaro": Forging Democratic Emotions
    "Happy in That Way"
    The Ancien Regime and the Male Voice: Shame, Disgust
    Females: Fraternity, Equality, Liberty [Liberté, égalité, fraternité]
    Creating a Man: "Mischievous Look," a "Good Outside Myself"
    Cherubino, Rousseau, Herder: Spaces for Craziness, "Dispositions of Peace"
    Transcending the Everyday? [Martha] Nussbaum contra [Charles O.] Nussbaum

After reading that chapter, I watched (again) three videotaped productions of that opera, one from the Glyndebourne Festival directed by Sir Peter Hall (1973)*, one from the Paris Opera directed by Giorgio Strehler (1980)*, and one from the Metropolitan Opera directed by Jean-Ponnelle (1985)#. I also watched one staged by Sir Thomas Allen (who sang the Count in the Met version above) with a young cast at the Royal College of Music and a couple of others online. I'm very familiar with the first three and as I read the chapter I recognized some of the ways their directors' interpretations and Allen's differed or matched Nussbaum's view of the opera, particularly the difference between the male characters' rivalry (the Count and Figaro/Bartolo and Figaro (still smarting over how Figaro helped the Count marry Rosina in Il Barbiere di Siviglia) and the female characters' partnership of equality and sympathy (the Countess Rosina and Susanna). 

In between these two contrasts, Nussbaum poses Cherubino, the young page, who moves between the two poles of the opera but identifies more with the women (in her view), certainly in his expressions of love and desire in his two arias as she contends--in both the Lyric Opera essay (and the book)--because "he has been educated by women and by music":
He talks about love. He is the only male in the opera (before the last act, at any rate) who has the slightest interest in that emotion. Certainly, the breathlessness of "Non so più" expresses the promiscuous quality, as well as the confusion, of adolescent infatuation. But it also contains romantic and poetic sentiments. The musical idiom, breathless and yet tender, is utterly unlike the tense accents of the adult males. When we reach the Countess's chamber, Cherubino's difference from other males becomes even more evident. Deeply infatuated with the Countess, he has decided to make her a present. What sort of present? What naturally occurs to him is to write a poem, set it to music, and sing it himself.

The content of that passion (in the beautiful aria "Voi che sapete") is remarkable for its utter difference from the arias of all the other males. First of all, Cherubino simply talks about love, and about its beautiful female object. He has nothing to say about other men, and he seems utterly impervious to questions of honor, shame, and competition. Second, he is eager to learn something, and he is eager to learn it from women: "You who know what sort of thing love is, women, tell me whether that is what I have in my heart." Third, unlike all the other males, he is utterly vulnerable, and he makes no attempt to conceal his vulnerability. Finally, and most remarkably, he locates what he is pursuing in a place outside of his own ego: "I seek a good that is outside myself." Hearing these words, we realize that no other male in the opera deigns to seek a good outside himself: all are preoccupied with winning a competitive victory, or shielding the ego from shame.
Cherubino, traditionally, is sung by a woman, a mezzo-soprano (although some recent productions I've seen online cast a male counter-tenor! How horrible; ruins the effect of the character's persona.), so that his natural community does seem to be among the women--the Countess and Susanna, Barbarina and the girls before the wedding, etc. He looks to Susanna and the Countess for protection; he certainly does not want to leave the Countess or go to war; as he tells Susanna, he really respects the Countess ("Ah, che troppo rispetto ella m'ispira!") He wants to stay where it's safe, with the women. As Beaumarchais wrote him, he's vulnerable.

Nussbaum offers a detailed analysis of the famous dressing up scene, as Susanna sings “Venite inginocchiatevi,” and certainly the Glyndebourne and Paris productions follow her lead (at the Met in the Ponnelle production Cherubino is behind a screen and we never see him in a girl's dress at all). Cherubino is happy to cooperate with Susanna and and she and the Countess in the first two productions are both amused and admiring of his transformation--since the Countess never sees Cherubino dressed as a girl in the Ponnelle, the scene relies on Susanna's aria alone. It seemed to me that the production by Sir Thomas Allen and a few others coarsened the character of Cherubino, depicting him as randy and rude, so that some of the charm Nussbaum looks for in this scene is absent.

Nussbaum emphasizes how different Cherubino is from the other men, but she does skip a crucial line during the last scene, when he is flirting with the Countess (thinking she's Susanna): why can't I do what the Count does everyday?: "E perche far io non posso/quelche il Conte or or fara?" He's learned something from the Count that the ladies won't appreciate. Nussbaum does admit that at the end of the opera when the Count has apologized and the Countess has accepted his apology, knowing his contrition will not last long:
Indeed, it seems far more likely that Cherubino will be corrupted by the male world around him than that the other men will drop their quest for honor and status and learn to sing like Cherubino.
Nor does Nussbaum contend with Barbarina's disrespectful conversation with the Count in front of the Countess in Act III, Scene 12 when Cherubino is discovered among the maidens at Court, not having joined the regiment, but dressed like one of the peasant girls. Barbarina reminds the Count that he promised her anything when they were kissing and cuddling. She wants to marry Cherubino, but she promises the Count that she'll still love him like a kitten:
BARBARINA Eccellenza, eccellenza, voi mi dite sì spesso, qual volta m'abbracciate e mi baciate: «Barbarina, se m'ami, ti darò quel che brami».
CONTE Io, dissi questo?
BARBARINA Voi. Or datemi, padrone, in sposo Cherubino, e v'amerò com'amo il mio gattino.
Poor Count; now he's a kitten? Barbarina seems more like the Count than the Countess or Susanna. And if Cherubino goes along, this a very different sort of reciprocity than Nussbaum is suggesting (is he willing to share Barbarina with the Count? That's not the kind of love either Susanna or the Countess want from their husbands). 

Nussbaum's other detailed analysis of Mozart's musical setting of Da Ponte's libretto (part of her argument is that Mozart sometimes emphasizes these ideas of fraternity, equality, and liberty musically more than Da Ponte does literarily) is of the duet between the Countess and Susanna in Act III, "Canzonetta sull'aria". She comments: "Their musical partnership expresses a kind of friendly attunement that is, we might say, an image of mutual respect, but also a reciprocal affection that is deeper than respect." She does refer to the scene in the Shawshank Redemption movie when Dufresne plays the duet over the prison loud speaker and Red describing the impression of beauty and freedom the prisoners experienced in spite of not understanding the words.

Nussbaum comments also on the finale with the Count's apology and the Countess's acceptance of it, noting that she knows he'll not reform. For the sake of at least some happiness, she accepts, after a pause, when his answer had been "no, no, no, no, no!" Thus, "Ah! Tutti contenti saremo così." "We'll alll be happy that way!"

Questo giorno di tormenti, 
di capricci e di follia, 
in contenti e in allegria solo 
Amor può terminar. 
Sposi, amici, al ballo! al gioco! 
Alle mine date fuoco, 
ed al suon di lieta marcia 
corriam tutti a festeggiar. 

This day of torment,
Of caprices and folly,
Love can end
Only in contentment and joy.
Lovers and friends, let's round things off
In dancing and pleasure,
And to the sound of a gay march
Let's hasten to the revelry.

[During this ensemble in the Ponnelle/Met Opera production, the men go to one side of the stage and the women on the other--and Cherubino's with the women!]

Thus she concludes: 
What that seems to mean is that all present say yes to a world that seeks and aims at reciprocity, respect, and attunement without being starry-eyed about perfection, a world in which people commit themselves to liberty, fraternity, and equality, while understanding that these transcendent ideals are not to be attained by exiting from the real world into a pristine world, but rather by pursuing them in this one . . .
And I would conclude that this is why the French Revolution devolved into terror, violence, and cruelty: the leaders did think they had to create a pristine world for their ideals to succeed--thus this week we'll mark Bastille Day (today) AND the feast of Carmelites of Compiegne (July 17), martyred because they wanted to practice their Faith and their vocations freely. Now there's an operatic finale (especially the 1987 performance from the Met of Poulenc's Dialogues of the Carmelites with Jessye Norman, Maria Ewing, Betsy Norden and a slashing blade in John Dexter's production! Readily available on line.)

Nevertheless, it does seem appropriate to post this today since it's Bastille Day. Beaumarchais's play had been banned in France because of its revolutionary tendencies. The Emperor Joseph allowed its performance and Da Ponte (not Mozart as in Amadeus!) assured him that the opera would not encourage those ideas.

I'm not commenting on the two more historical or philosophical chapters because this post is already long and my main interest is in Nussbaum's interpretation of the opera (the libretto and the score) not so much the background to Mozart's interest in this view of the society of the Almaviva household. I think that will be different in the next chapter about the influence of Freemasonry on Idomeneo and Die Zauberflote.

I might just comment on the Mozart chapters on this blog. 

*These two performances are available on YouTube.
#The Metropolitan Opera performance is available for rental or with a membership at Met on Demand 

Image Credit: Fair Use of Cover in a book review.

Tuesday, May 5, 2026

Learning Something New Every Single Day!

Earlier this week, recovering from an allergic reaction with a rash and swelling all over my face--two trips to the Immediate Care and ER; pills and potions, etc, etc.--I found out that Igor Stravinsky composed a Catholic Mass between 1944 and 1948. According to some quotations in a Wikipedia article:

"My Mass was partly provoked by some Masses of Mozart that I found at a secondhand store in Los Angeles in 1942 or 1943. As I played through these rococo-operatic sweets-of-sin, I knew I had to write a Mass of my own, but a real one."
— Igor Stravinsky to Robert Craft[1]
And although he was a Russian Orthodox Christian, he had to write a Catholic Mass if he wanted to have orchestral accompaniment, so:
I wanted my Mass to be used liturgically, an outright impossibility as far as the Russian Church was concerned, as Orthodox tradition proscribes musical instruments in its services- and as I can endure unaccompanied singing in only the most harmonically primitive music.[4]
I don't appreciate his comments about Mozart's Masses ("these rococo-operatic sweets-of-sin"!), but I appreciated his setting of the Mass, especially the Credo.
One composes a march to facilitate marching men, so with my Credo I hope to provide an aid to the text. The Credo is the longest movement. There is much to believe.[4]
You may find several performances on YouTube and on CD (perhaps available used?)

Stravinsky's comment about Mozart's "rococo-operatic" Masses reminded me of Kenneth Clark's description in Civilisation of how listening to the G minor Quintet changed his mind about that characterization of him:
And yet to pronounce the name of Mozart in the Amahenburg is dangerous . It gives colour -- very pretty colour -- to the notion that Mozart was merely a Rococo composer. Fifty years ago this was what most people thought about him, and the notion was supported by horrible little plaster busts which made him look the perfect eighteenth-century dummy. I bought one of these busts when I was at school, but when I first heard the G minor Quintet I realised that it couldn't have been written by the smooth, white character on my mantelpiece and threw the bust into the wastepaper basket. I afterwards discovered the Lange portrait [169] which, although no masterpiece, does convey the single-mindedness of genius. Of course a lot of Mozart's music is in the current eighteenth-century style. He was so much at home in this golden age of music, and so completely the master of its forms, that he didn't feel it necessary to destroy them. Indeed he loved the clarity and the precision that had been brought to perfection in the music of his time. I like the story of Mozart sitting at table absentmindedly folding and refolding his napkin into more and more elaborate patterns, as fresh musical ideas passed through his mind. But this formal perfection was used to express two characteristics which were very far from the Rococo style. One of them was that peculiar kind of melancholy, a melancholy amounting almost to panic, which so often haunts the isolation of genius. Mozart felt it quite young. The other characteristic was almost the opposite: a passionate interest in human beings, and in the drama of human relationships. How often in Mozart's orchestral pieces - concertos or quartets - we find our- selves participating in a drama or dialogue; and of course this feeling reaches its natural conclusion in opera.

I love to listen to Mozart's operas! Le Nozze di Figaro, Don Giovanni, Idomeneo, La Clemenza di Tito, Cosi fan Tutte, and Die Zauberflöte! Especially Le Nozze di Figaro!! 

And I enjoy listening to lots of Mozart's music in general, as often demonstrated on this blog. 

Finally, I'm not sure how settings of the Catholic Mass--especially by a composer like Mozart--could ever be considered "sweets-of-sin"!

Nevertheless, I recommend you listen to Stravinsky's Catholic Mass!

Image Credit (Public Domain) Photoportrait of Russian composer Igor Stravinsky. Taken by George Grantham Bain's news picture agency.

Image Credit (Public Domain): Act 1: Cherubino hides behind Susanna's chair as the count arrives.

Tuesday, February 24, 2026

Mozart's Church Music Via "Another Route"

Sometimes you think you've lived before 
All that you live today 
Things you do come back to you 
As though they knew the way 
Oh, the tricks your mind can play!
--Lorenz Hart, "Where or When", from Babes in Arms

I could revise this verse slightly: "Sometimes you think you've read before/All that you read today"' especially when I read a chapter from Charles Scribner III's new book Artists & Authors: A Life in Good Company. 

The book as a whole is divided into three parts: Authors ("Books and Company": Hemingway, Fitzgerald, and Woolf at Scribner's); Artists ("Old Masters": Bernini, Rubens, Caravaggio, Michelangelo); Singers ("The Vocal Arts": Sacred Music, Schwarzkopf, von Stade, and Costa).
 
[Please note that von Stade is singing "Where or When" in the link above.]

It was in that "Sacred Music" chapter that Scribner wrote about Mozart's sacred (Church) music as Dietrich von Hildebrand had done in his comments in MOZART BEETHOVEN SCHUBERT and in the "Sacred Music" excerpt from Aesthetics, Volume 2. I think that von Hildebrand and Scribner agree on "the quintessentially Catholic character" of Mozart's Church music.

Scribner advises: 
The common wisdom used to be that Mozart's religious music was merely "for hire", something he knocked off to earn a living so that he could write the music--operas, symphonies, chamber pieces--he really loved. What a surprise, then, to read that his widow, Constanze, said that his favorite genre of all was church music. A close study of Mozart's sacred music confirms Constanze's claim. (p. 139)

He goes on to comment on Mozart's Vesperae solennes de confessore, K339 that it "was as carefully composed as anything Mozart ever wrote" with due attention to the "texts of psalms and canticles". He also highlights the "Dona nobis pacem" of the Coronation Mass in C-major that its peace "is not a passive one--not the absence of pain or conflict, but rather the consummation of joy." (p. 140)

[Please note that I purchased Artists & Authors and enjoyed reading Scribner's chapters on the authors, artists, and singers he highlights. For one thing, I learned how to describe the Crucifix at my home parish, Blessed Sacrament: as a "Christo Vivo"; His eyes are open and His side has not been pierced!]

After reading those comments, I pulled out my copy of a "Double Decca" set of some of Mozart's sacred music, including Vesperae Solennes De Confessore, K339; Vesperae De Dominica, K321; Litaniae, K243; Litaniae Lauretanae, K195, and the "Spaur-Messe", K258. In Kenneth Chalmers' notes he quotes a letter Mozart sent to Padre Martini in September 1776, in which the twenty-year-old writes about his "current activities in Salzburg" that "My father is in charge of music in the cathedral, and this gives me an opportunity to write as much church music as I like . . ." Mozart further comments on the challenge of the Prince Archbishop's time restrictions (a Mass was not to last more than 45 minutes): "Special care is needed with this sort of composition." Archbishop Colloredo was responding to Pope Benedict XIV's 1749 encyclical "Annus qui" (which was a Jubilee Year) to, according to Chalmers, "focus on clarity, and on an identifiably 'sacred' idiom". (p. 5)

Chalmers states that Mozart and the Prince Archbishop Colloredo did not get along ("possibly exacerbated by the very limitations imposed on sacred music" p. 6) and Mozart did want to write more operas but concludes on page 7 that he wanted to present copies of both the confessore and Dominica Vespers to Baron van Sweeten in March of 1783, indicating that he valued them.

Nevertheless, one would have to twist Mozart's words to imply that he didn't want to compose that much Church music!

Monday, April 4, 2016

Nonesuch Mozart



So we (my husband and I) went to Mass at the Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception on Thursday last week for noon Mass; then we ate lunch at La Galette (he had soup and salad; I had the special: cabbage rolls and salad and I brought leftovers home). Then we checked out Spektrum Muzik and bought two more Nonesuch albums, My husband also found a used copy of the Chicago Transit Authority double album (sans posters) and we selected a Stan Kenton album too.

On the Mozart symphony album, Edward Tatnall Canby wrote the notes and he commented on how precarious the Mozart family life was. Wolfgang Amadeus seemed to thrive on a nomadic lifestyle, constantly moving, staying ahead of the creditors and landlords, borrowing money and promising to repay without any reasonable expectation of meeting the obligation. Edward Tatnall Canby asks, "Why didn't anyone help Mozart?" Josef Haydn tried to help Mozart, but Mozart, per Canby, did not avail himself of the opportunities Haydn or others offered. As Canby concludes, "Mozart was just plain maladjusted--and therefore misunderstood. If we seem blunt in our judgment, it is only because we are sympathetic. If he could not, would not help himself, we understand. The miracle is his music."

In all that disarray, how did Mozart create those three great symphonies in one summer (1788); Numbers 39, 40, and 41? Canby notes that Mozart's technique and style were so secure that all the confusion around him could not distract him. I think there's a moment in the Milos Forman adaptation of Peter Shaffer's Amadeus that depicts Mozart composing while his wife and father argue in the other room. Canby suggests that Mozart's creativity "was his release from painful reality. Here was the modern escape mechanism in a classic form!" Canby goes on to note the contrast between Mozart's "life of tragedy and the serene perfection of his music" which is "the supreme confidence of a master of style and technique." Finally, Canby concludes: "In Mozart's case--and this was his genius--the escape world of composition was so solid, so disciplined, as to far outshadow reality itself. So it is with most great minds. Maladjustment today, immortality tomorrow."

Wednesday, March 16, 2016

Monteverdi, Mozart, and Handel




My husband and I concluded our auditions of the other three LPs we purchased last week. My husband offers these particulars re: our stereo equipment: all of these records were "played on recycled "green" classic stereo equipment from the 70's and 80's: NAD 7100 receiver, Boston Acoustics A70 speakers, and Yamaha YP-B2 turntable." He has another turntable that he considers better for rock and roll. He is the audiophile, obviously.

The Handel and Mozart discs he considered excellent as far as their condition and sound fidelity. The Monteverdi Madrigals were recorded at a very low sound level: he had the volume on the NAD turned up pretty high.

Peter Frankl, the soloist on the Mozart piano concertos record, is on the faculty of the Yale School of Music and just turned 80 last October! He was 30 years old when he recorded that Turnabout album with the Wurttemberg Chamber Orchestra:

Pianist Peter Frankl made his London debut in 1962 and his New York debut with the Cleveland Orchestra under George Szell in 1967. Since that time he has performed with many of the world’s finest orchestras, including the Berlin Philharmonic, Concertgebouw, Israel Philharmonic, Orchestre de Paris, all the London orchestras, and the major American orchestras. He has collaborated with such eminent conductors as Abbado, Boulez, Davis, Haitink, Maazel, Masur, Muti, Salonen, and Solti, and his world tours have taken him to Japan, Korea, Australia, New Zealand, and South Africa. He has appeared over twenty times at London’s BBC Promenade Concerts and has been a regular participant at the Edinburgh, Cheltenham, Aldeburgh, Verbier, Kumho, and Casals Festivals.

In the United States, Peter Frankl has been a regular guest artist at festivals including Aspen, Chautauqua, Marlboro, Norfolk, Ravinia, Santa Fe, and Yellow Barn. For many years the Frankl-Pauk-Kirshbaum Trio traveled the world. His many chamber music partners have included Kyung Wha Chung, Peter Csaba, Ralph Kirshbaum, and the Tokyo, Takács, Guarneri, Bartók, Fine Arts, and Lindsay quartets. He has given master classes all over the world, including the Royal Academy and Royal College in London, the Liszt Academy in Budapest, Van Cliburn Institute in Texas, and in Beijing, Hong Kong, and Seoul.

Among his recordings are the complete works for piano by Schumann and Debussy, Bartók and Chopin solo albums, a Hungarian anthology, concertos and four-hand works by Mozart, the two Brahms piano concertos, the Brahms violin and clarinet sonatas, the Brahms trios, Bartók pieces for violin and piano, and the piano quintets by Brahms, Schumann, Dvorák, Martinu, and both Dohnányis.

In recognition of his artistic achievements, Mr. Frankl was awarded the Officer’s Cross by the Hungarian Republic, and on his seventieth birthday he was given one of the highest civilian awards in Hungary for his lifetime artistic achievement in the world of music. He is an honorary professor of the Liszt Academy and has been on the Yale School of Music faculty since 1987.

The two piano concertos date from Mozart's Vienna period, one composed in 1782 (n. 11) and the other in 1784 (n. 15). You may hear a sample of the 11th concerto here and the 15th here.

The Handel was performed by the Cento Soli (One Hundred Soloists) Orchestra of Paris, about whom I can find no further information. The Monteverdi Madrigals were performed by the Nuovo Madrigaletto Italiano and I hoped to find a list of the singers because their voices were so wonderful. Edward Tatnall Canby provides the notes again and explains away the lack of translation by stating the lyrics can't be adequately translated anyway!

Tuesday, October 6, 2015

The Original Miserere from the Sistine Chapel


The new album from the Sistine Chapel Choir contains a different version of Allegri's Miserere than we are used to, as this site explains:

The Deutsche Grammophon-recorded album even includes a world premiere, but it's not one you’d expect. Allegri’s Miserere may have been topping the classical charts for years, but the Sistine Chapel’s performance of the work in its original form (from the Sistine Codex of 1661) is, unbelievably, the first of its kind. Hardly anyone alive today will have heard the Miserere as Allegri originally conceived it. The version that most of us know – below, with its thrilling high C in the semichorus – is from a much later transcription.

‘The version of the
Miserere that most people are familar with is based on a later transcription, most probably the one made by [former choir director] Lorenzo Perosi at the beginning of the 20th century,’ says Palombella [the current choir director]. ‘That version has the additions of many Vatican singers, but we have now recorded the true, Renaissance Miserere.

'It’s very simple, very clear, and we are singing it as authentically as possible, given what we know about the choir’s history. The soloist on the recording sings from the Salla Regia next to the Sistine Chapel, and we have also used two male cantuses [countertenors] in the semi-chorus rather than boy singers, because this is most probably how it was done in the past.’

The article also addresses the story of Mozart's secretive transcription of the music:

Allegri’s famous setting of Psalm 51 is already the stuff of legend – not least because of the widely-circulated tale about Mozart allegedly defying papal law by smuggling it out of the Vatican using memory alone. According to the story, the 14-year-old Mozart heard the Miserere during Mass on a visit to Rome in 1770 and wrote it down from memory that evening. Is it true?

‘I can believe the Mozart story is true,' says Palombella, 'but mostly because it’s very easy to transcribe the
Miserere! The harmony is always the same, and it’s repeated many times. But the part about the music not being allowed to leave the Vatican is probably a myth. It is true that music was written specifically for the Sistine Chapel, and that there was a sort of copyright, but if a pope was asked to have the scores sent somewhere else, generally he accepted.’

The story I've linked includes two versions of the Miserere: one by The Sixteen (the one with the high C) and the one by the Sistine Chapel Choir. More background on the composition here. 

Saturday, July 11, 2015

Emeritus Pope Benedict's Honorary Degrees and Sacred Music

From Vatican Radio:

Pope-emeritus Benedict XVI received Doctorates honoris causa on Saturday from the Pontifical John Paul II University of Krakow and the Krakow Academy of Music. The motivation for the honors issued by the University’s Academic Senate specifies five contributions Pope Benedict has made to knowledge and culture: his great respect for the musical tradition of the Church and remarkable sensitivity to the music of faith; the life-long and constant demonstration of a special concern for the noble beauty of sacred music and its proper place in the celebration of the sacred liturgical rites of the Church; his constant insistence on the didactic importance of the via pulchritudinis – the way of beauty – which can become a way of knowing and worshiping God for the modern man; his lifelong commitment to Truth, which strengthens the Christian faith in times of spiritual confusion caused by liberalism, postmodernism and relativism, and his tireless efforts to restore the spiritual dimension of Europe; his kind support for the work of transforming the schools of the Pontifical Academy of Theology into the Pontifical John Paul II University.

Father Benedict had some prepared remarks. In The Spectator, Damian Thompson writes:

One of the finest speeches Benedict XVI ever delivered was about sacred music. It is a small masterpiece, in which Benedict recalls his first encounter with Mozart in the liturgy. ‘When the first notes of the Coronation Mass sounded, Heaven virtually opened and the presence of the Lord was experienced very profoundly,’ he said.

Benedict robustly defended the performance of the work of great composers at Mass, which he insisted was necessary for the fulfilment of the Second Vatican Council’s wish that ‘the patrimony of sacred music [is] preserved and developed with great care’.

Then he asked: what is music? He identified three places from which it flowed. First, the experience of love, opening ‘a new grandeur and breadth of reality’ that inspires music. Second, ‘the experience of sadness, death, sorrow and the abysses of existence’. These open ‘in an opposite direction, new dimensions of reality that can no longer find answers in discourses alone’. Third, the encounter with the divine. ‘I find it moving to observe how, in the Psalms, singing is no longer enough for men — an appeal is made to all the instruments: reawakened is the hidden music of creation, its mysterious language.’

Our musical Pope Emeritus changed liturgical music practices at St. Peter's, as this Crisis article notes, and those changes have reverberated throughout the Church:

Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger was different. He had written an entire book on the music issue. He had written another book on the liturgical question. He had spoken about the subject on many occasions. He never feared the subject and this is for two reasons: 1) he understood the goals of Vatican II and saw that they had been seriously distorted, and 2) he was a trained music (sic) of the highest calibre who understood the role of music in the Roman Rite.

When he became Pope, the changes began and they were relentless. We started hearing chant in Papal liturgy, just a bit at first and then more as time went on. With
Summorum Pontificum (2007) he took away the stigma that had been attached to traditional chant by granting full permission to the liturgical structure that had originally given rise to chant. This was deeply encouraging for a generation that was ready to move forward. We started seeing chant workshops fill up. Groups began to form at the parish level. New resources started to be published by independent publishers. A real fire had been lit in the Catholic music world. And it all happened without any impositions or legislation.

The musical program of St. Peter’s Basilica began to attract the attention of serious musicians. A new standard came to be applied to visiting choirs: you must know the basics of Gregorian chant or you cannot sing at St. Peter’s. This was a gigantic decision that fundamentally upset the dynamic that had long developed between Rome and traveling choirs. Now choirs had to learn and discover chant if they hoped to take that long-sought pilgrimage to Rome.

Meanwhile, Joseph Ratzinger’s writings on music were selling more than ever, and having an ever larger influence. Benedict XVI spoke about the topic often in homilies and spontaneous remarks following concerts. He worked to elevate high art to a new status on his travels. His team worked hard to encourage groups that sang for liturgy for his trips to embrace chant and polyphonic music of the Renaissance. It didn’t always work but the progress was obvious.

Read the rest there. The issue that Pope Benedict addressed was that the Church, in the wake of the Second Vatican Council, had mistakenly jettisoned our great heritage of beautiful Gregorian chant, Renaissance polyphonic Mass settings, and even high classical Masses, like Mozart's Coronation Mass. The fathers at Vatican II had said positively that Gregorian chant should have pride of place in the celebration of the liturgy, and yet I grew up never hearing chant at all--until it became popular as background music and the different chant discs (for Meditation, Relaxation, etc) came out. 

This reminds me of course of that "Agatha Christie Indult" letter, the one sent from England to Pope Paul VI, descrying the elimination of the traditional Latin Mass. Remember that it was signed by many non-Catholics and several musicians and they were concerned of the loss of so much culture:

The rite in question, in its magnificent Latin text, has also inspired a host of priceless achievements in the arts - not only mystical works, but works by poets, philosophers, musicians, architects, painters and sculptors in all countries and epochs. Thus, it belongs to universal culture as well as to churchmen and formal Christians. In the materialistic and technocratic civilisation that is increasingly threatening the life of mind and spirit in its original creative expression - the word - it seems particularly inhuman to deprive man of word-forms in one of their most grandiose manifestations. The signatories of this appeal, which is entirely ecumenical and non-political, have been drawn from every branch of modern culture in Europe and elsewhere.

Perhaps along with the Anglican Ordinariate, this revival in sacred and liturgical music will be one of Pope Benedict's greatest legacies, God bless him!

St. Benedict of Nursia, pray for us!

Tuesday, January 20, 2015

Pope Benedict XVI: Music, Beauty, and Prayer


We watched this DVD last week and will need to watch it or listen to the music again, at least--especially to hear Hilary Hahn's own credenzas in the Mozart violin concerto. The concert was broadcast live in 2007 on April 16, Pope Emeritus Benedict's 80th birthday. Other than the opening remarks and the pope's final remarks, the musical selections on the disc are:

Giovanni Gabrieli (1553 - 1612)
Canzon noni toni a 12, C 183 (rev. by T. Unger)
Stuttgart Radio Brass, Gustavo Dudamel

Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756 - 1791)
Violin Concerto No.3 in G, K.216
1. Allegro
2. Adagio
3. Rondo (Allegro)
Hilary Hahn, Radio-Sinfonieorchester Stuttgart, Gustavo Dudamel

Antonín Dvorák (1841 - 1904)
Symphony No.9 in E Minor, Op.95 "From the New World"
1. Adagio - Allegro molto
2. Largo
3. Scherzo (Molto vivace)
4. Allegro con fuoco
Radio-Sinfonieorchester Stuttgart, Gustavo Dudamel

Giovanni Gabrieli (1553 - 1612)
Sonata XIII (rev. by T. Unger)
Stuttgart Radio Brass, Gustavo Dudamel

One reason why I'd just like to listen to the music is that the video images are rather limited--either close-ups of the soloist, conductor, or sections of the orchestra or wide angles of the hall (the Paul VI audience hall) and the audience. There is no middle. Even if people were enjoying the music their expressions--even Pope Benedict's--did not necessary show it.

Pope Benedict thanked the musicians after the concert and discussed his love of music and its universal language of beauty:

Above all, I would now like to thank the musicians of this evening's event, the members of the Stuttgarter Radio-Sinfonieorchesters, the SWR, who with their skill have offered us all an authentic experience of the inspiring power of great music.

I thank Gustavo Dudamel, the conductor, and Hilary Hahn, the soloist, and all of you, Ladies and Gentlemen. Since the language of music is universal, we see people from completely different cultural and religious backgrounds who let themselves be gripped and likewise guided by it and who also interpret it.

Today, this universal aspect of music is given special emphasis, thanks to the electronic and digital instruments of communications. How many people there are in the most diverse countries who are able to take part in this musical performance at home, or experience it later!

I am convinced that music - and here I am thinking in particular of the great Mozart and this evening, of course, of the marvellous music by Gabrieli and the majestic "New World" by Dvorák - really is the universal language of beauty which can bring together all people of good will on earth and get them to lift their gaze on high and open themselves to the Absolute Good and Beauty whose ultimate source is God himself.

In looking back over my life, I thank God for placing music beside me, as it were, as a travelling companion that has offered me comfort and joy. I also thank the people who from the very first years of my childhood brought me close to this source of inspiration and serenity.

I thank those who combine music and prayer in harmonious praise of God and his works: they help us glorify the Creator and Redeemer of the world, which is the marvellous work of his hands.

This is my hope: that the greatness and beauty of music will also give you, dear friends, new and continuous inspiration in order to build a world of love, solidarity and peace.


After hearing that first sentence in the last paragraph I thought about a CD we'd just rediscovered: Music from Holy Cross Monastery in Austria by Alberich Mazak, from the SEON label that was purchased by Sony Music. Mazak was a monk at the monastery in the seventeenth century (he lived from 1609 to 1661, who studied music and philosophy before becoming a priest and monk. According to the liner notes, he wrote "masses, litanies, sacred cantatas, psalms, offertories, antiphons and even simple German pieces." Unfortunately, we don't have the works contained in his Opus Three, which "presumably contained Mazak's most progressive style and represented the climax of his work". Holy Cross Monastery maintains a website and even records some of Mazak's music on their YouTube channel (The Monastic Channel). 

Pope Benedict visited Holy Cross Monastery in September of 2007 and commented on prayer and chant in the monastic life:

Dear brother priests and deacons, dear brothers and sisters in the consecrated life! I realize that discipline is needed, and sometimes great effort as well, in order to recite the Breviary faithfully; but through this officium we also receive many riches: how many times, in doing so, have we seen our weariness and despondency melt away! When God is faithfully praised and worshiped, his blessings are unfailing. In Austria, people rightly say: “Everything depends on God’s blessing!”.

Your primary service to this world must therefore be your prayer and the celebration of the divine Office. The interior disposition of each priest, and of each consecrated person, must be that of “putting nothing before the divine Office”. The beauty of this inner attitude will find expression in the beauty of the liturgy, so that wherever we join in singing, praising, exalting and worshipping God, a little bit of heaven will become present on earth. Truly it would not be presumptuous to say that, in a liturgy completely centred on God, we can see, in its rituals and chant, an image of eternity. Otherwise, how could our forefathers, hundreds of years ago, have built a sacred edifice as solemn as this? Here the architecture itself draws all our senses upwards, towards “what eye has not seen, nor ear heard, nor the heart of man imagined: what God has prepared for those who love him” (1 Cor 2:9). In all our efforts on behalf of the liturgy, the determining factor must always be our looking to God. We stand before God – he speaks to us and we speak to him. Whenever in our thinking we are only concerned about making the liturgy attractive, interesting and beautiful, the battle is already lost. Either it is Opus Dei, with God as its specific subject, or it is not. In the light of this, I ask you to celebrate the sacred liturgy with your gaze fixed on God within the communion of saints, the living Church of every time and place, so that it will truly be an expression of the sublime beauty of the God who has called men and women to be his friends!

The soul of prayer, ultimately, is the Holy Spirit. Whenever we pray, it is he who “helps us in our weakness, interceding for us with sighs too deep for words” (Rom 8:26). Trusting in these words of the Apostle Paul, I assure you, dear brothers and sisters, that prayer will produce in you the same effect which once led to the custom of calling priests and consecrated persons simply “spirituals” (Geistliche). Bishop Sailer of Regensburg once said that priests should be first and foremost spiritual persons. I would like to see a revival of the word “Geistliche”. More importantly, though, the content of that word should become a part of our lives: namely, that in following the Lord, we become, by the power of the Spirit, “spiritual” men and women.

Timely words for this year dedicated by Pope Francis to the Consecrated Life!

Sunday, September 28, 2014

Mozart's Salzburg Church Sonatas


Over our 23-year and counting marriage, my husband and I have purchased many compact discs of many musical types: I'm a little bit classical and he's a little bit rock and roll. We went "shopping" in the cd racks last Friday night and found this 1988 recording of Mozart's Church Sonatas, or Epistle Sonatas with Peter Hurford as organist, the Amsterdam Mozart Players, and several other artists.

So soon after reading Mosebach's book on Catholic liturgy, I thought of how strangely these musical interludes must have broken up the celebration of the Mass. They were performed between the Epistle and the Gospel and thus pre-empted the Gradual and the Alleluia! They are all sprightly and, as the liner notes say, "their purpose was to highlight and herald the proclamation of the Gospel", to announce the Good News and thus all are in Major keys.

Mozart wrote them for the two Archbishops of Salzburg he served, Sigismund and Colloredo. Also according to the liner notes by Ann Bond, three of these 17 Epistle Sonatas were designated for specific Masses, and I've linked recordings of two of those Masses that include the Epistle Sonata:

K263 with the Organ Mass, K259
K329 with the Coronation Mass, K317 (conducted by the late Christopher Hogwood)
K336 with the Missa Solemnis, K337

The cd is still readily available at Amazon.com and other online cd shops--ours has the London logo, not the Decca.

Saturday, August 9, 2014

Mozart's Sister, the Dauphin and the Abbess

My husband and I rented this French language film from Amazon.com and watched it Thursday night. It is a fictionalized account of the early life of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart's sister, Maria Anna, nicknamed Nannerl. The movie depicts the Mozart family on tour, enduring disappointment, delays, and other misfortunes along the way. Both Wolfgang and Nannerl tire of their father's lying about their ages to make their musical prodigality appear more amazing, and forcing them to practice, practice, practice!

The film is beautifully made, with scenes filmed at Versailles and in Paris (I recognized the Chapelle de la Vierge with its musical angels at St. Germain L'Auxerrois, next to the Louvre). The plot is entirely imaginary, of course, as Nannerl, dressed as a boy, visits the Dauphin of France, writes a violin concerto for him, and is devastated by his ultimate response.

She also meets the Dauphin's three sisters in their convent retreat (when the axle breaks on their coach as the Mozart family travels to Paris). Louise, the youngest of Louis XV's children, and Nannerl become friends, as Nannerl is her messenger to the man Louise plans to marry. But Louise instead decides to join the Carmel at St. Denis, praying in reparation for her father's sins. As Sr. Therese of Saint Augustine, she eventually becomes Abbess at St. Denis. According to this Wikipedia article, her last words were: Au paradis! Vite! Au grand galop!" ("To paradise! Fast! At the great gallop!). She was declared Venerable by Pope Pius IX.

After the movie it was fun to try to explain all the Dauphins and the succession of the House of Bourbon to my husband. The Dauphin in this movie was the son of Louis XV and father of Louis XVI, Louis XVIII, and Charles X. He was also named Louis and died in 1765, before his father died, and thus never reigned. Mozart's Sister depicts him as mentally unstable, morbid, and even sexually ambivalent. The "trouser role" Nannerl plays creates the same tension and uncertainty as Cherubino in Le Nozze di Figaro. There was one musical detail I wondered about--the Dauphin asks the trousered Nannerl if she can sing Gregorio Allegri's Miserere; I thought that the music for the Miserere wasn't widely available until Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart transcribed it in 1771, and the action in this movie predates his visit to the Sistine Chapel. The Dauphin wants to know if he/she can sing the beautiful high notes of that setting of Psalm 51--and she/he can!